I’ve always been drawn to the idea of exploring a place not only for its sights but for its tastes. On a recent trip to Barrie, Ontario, I found myself on a quest to discover the best seafood restaurants this charming city had to offer. With its proximity to the Great Lakes, Barrie boasts an abundance of fresh and delicious seafood, and it was hard not to get excited about the culinary delights that awaited me.
If you’re a seafood lover or just someone who enjoys a good meal by the water, Barrie is definitely a place you need to consider for your next trip. In this post, I’ll be sharing some of the best seafood restaurants in Barrie, along with my personal experiences, so you can have a flavorful and unforgettable time when you visit.
1. Why Barrie for Seafood?
Barrie’s location on the shores of Lake Simcoe gives it a natural edge when it comes to fresh, locally sourced seafood. The lake is known for its clean waters, and the surrounding area has a long history of fishing. This makes it an ideal place to enjoy fresh fish and shellfish. Whether you’re in the mood for something casual by the water or an upscale dining experience, there’s no shortage of places to indulge in a seafood feast.
2. The Fishbowl Restaurant: A Waterfront Delight
One of the first places I headed to after arriving in Barrie was The Fishbowl Restaurant, located right on the waterfront. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by a laid-back, nautical-themed ambiance, complete with wooden decks, coastal decorations, and large windows that offered a fantastic view of the lake.
The menu immediately stood out, offering a wide range of fresh seafood options. I opted for the Lake Simcoe Perch—a local favorite—and was impressed by how delicate and flavorful it was. The fish was perfectly pan-seared, crispy on the outside, and tender on the inside. The accompanying garlic butter sauce was rich and added just the right amount of flavor without overpowering the natural taste of the perch.
For starters, I had the Oysters Rockefeller, which were absolutely mouthwatering. Baked to perfection with a blend of creamy spinach, cheese, and a hint of anise from the fennel, they were a perfect way to start the meal. The Fishbowl also has an extensive wine list, and I paired my meal with a crisp, chilled white wine that complemented the delicate flavors of the seafood beautifully.
Pro Tip: If you’re visiting Barrie in the summer, I recommend reserving a table on the patio. Dining al fresco by the water while enjoying fresh seafood is an experience you won’t want to miss.
3. The Keg Steakhouse + Bar: Seafood with a Touch of Class
While Barrie is known for its seafood offerings, the city also features some high-end dining options that integrate seafood into their menus. One of the standout spots for a more upscale meal is The Keg Steakhouse + Bar. Though it is primarily known for its steaks, this location also offers excellent seafood dishes, including Grilled Atlantic Lobster Tail and Garlic Shrimp Scampi.
I decided to try the lobster tail, and it was one of the best I’ve ever had. Cooked just right, with a slightly smoky flavor from the grill and a rich butter glaze, the lobster tail was the star of the plate. The dish came with roasted vegetables and mashed potatoes, which complemented the seafood perfectly.
Although the atmosphere here is more refined than a typical seafood shack, the service was relaxed and welcoming. It’s the kind of place where you can dress up a little, but still feel at ease while enjoying your meal. If you’re in the mood for some extra indulgence, don’t miss out on their Seafood Tower, which is a beautiful presentation of oysters, shrimp, lobster, and crab.
4. The Dockside Fish & Chips: Casual Dining by the Lake
For a more casual and affordable option, The Dockside Fish & Chips is a must-visit. This small, family-run establishment right by the lake serves some of the best fish and chips I’ve had in a long time. Known for its fresh catch, the place has a cozy, no-frills vibe perfect for a laid-back lunch.
I ordered the Fish and Chips Special, which featured freshly battered cod fillets served with golden crispy fries. The cod was light and flaky, with a slight sweetness that came through in every bite. The batter was perfectly crispy but not greasy, and the fries were exactly how you want them—crispy on the outside, soft and fluffy on the inside.
The highlight here, though, is the homemade tartar sauce. Creamy and tangy with just a hint of dill, it paired beautifully with the fish. It was a simple but satisfying meal, and sometimes that’s exactly what you need when you’re in the mood for something comforting.
Insider Tip: The restaurant is often packed, especially on weekends, so it’s a good idea to place your order ahead of time through the SkipTheDishes app or by calling in for takeout. If you’re in Barrie for a longer stay, try ordering for a picnic by the lake!
5. Captain George’s Fish & Chips: A Local Tradition
For many locals, Captain George’s Fish & Chips is a staple, and after dining there, I can see why. This family-owned establishment has been serving Barrie’s residents and visitors alike for decades. The restaurant offers a variety of seafood options, but I was particularly drawn to the classic Halibut Fish & Chips.
The halibut was so tender that it practically melted in my mouth. The batter was thick and crispy, providing just the right amount of crunch. Unlike other places that might drown their fish in oil, Captain George’s strikes a perfect balance, making each bite feel light yet satisfying. The fries were golden brown and seasoned just right, and I loved how the meal was served with a generous side of mushy peas—something that added a little extra touch of authenticity to the dish.
What I loved about Captain George’s was not only the food but also the atmosphere. The casual, beachy vibe made it the perfect spot for a quick but delicious seafood meal. They even offer family platters, which are great for those visiting with a group or looking to sample a little bit of everything.
6. Online Ordering: A Convenient Way to Enjoy Seafood at Home
One thing that made my trip to Barrie even more enjoyable was discovering the convenience of ordering food online. Barrie has embraced platforms like SkipTheDishes and Uber Eats, making it easier than ever to enjoy top-tier seafood from the comfort of your accommodation or even at the park by the lake.
I used SkipTheDishes to place a takeout order from The Dockside Fish & Chips one evening when I wanted to enjoy some fresh fish while relaxing by the waterfront. The app made it easy to browse the menu, customize my order, and have my food delivered directly to me. The convenience was especially great when I was craving something comforting without wanting to sit down at a restaurant.
If you’re staying in Barrie for an extended period or just want to try a variety of places without having to leave your room, these platforms are a great option. Plus, many restaurants, especially the more casual ones, offer discounts or promotions for first-time online orders, so it’s worth checking out the deals before you decide where to order from.
7. Wrapping Up the Seafood Experience
There’s something truly special about experiencing Barrie through its seafood offerings. The city’s diverse range of eateries—from casual fish and chip shops to upscale seafood restaurants—means there’s something for every kind of seafood lover. With fresh, local catches available year-round, Barrie provides a true taste of the Great Lakes that’s hard to beat.
Whether you find yourself sitting on a sun-drenched patio overlooking the lake or enjoying a cozy dinner inside a family-run joint, you’re bound to have a memorable dining experience in Barrie. The combination of quality ingredients, local flavors, and warm, welcoming service make these seafood spots stand out.
I’m already planning my next visit, and I have a feeling that Barrie’s seafood scene will be calling me back again soon.
